While he is one of the most respected Superheroes on Earth, that is due to his impressive leadership and sense of duty, for although he is a superhuman he is not super powerful, with many other superheroes ranking well above him in … Captain America represents who we can strive to become, while Superman is who we dream we could be. Both MUTOs. Hmmm, I wouldn't really wanna consider alternative versions/universes. The only reason Superman became an evil dictator was because he was just super bad a ruling shit. She could put Hulk and Thor in their place. Captain America Comics #1 (Timely, 1941) CGC VF+ 8.5 Off-white pages. Batman. King Kong (Skull Island version) Large Skullcrawler. Superman has had to fight people of his own race who believe he should rule the planet due to his superiority. Story wise depends on the writers, in main timeline none of the heroes would go bad and will always resist any temptation. IMO, the reason Batman's got such rigidly defined morals is because he's too insaine to be able to feel his way through a moral landscape. Ironman (Endgame) Worthy Captain America. 1 year ago More so than Superman, who gained super status because he landed on Earth, the more relatable Cap earned a chance (and not guarantee) at his through tenacity. The ones who played Superman are Brandon Ruth, Christopher Reeve and Henry Cavill. This kind of nepotism puts him below Superman. Captain America is also a normal dude pushed to the pinnacle of human condition. Member. Then in a half of a second, Amazo used Hawkgirl's mace, Batman's martial arts skill to deliver a thousand blow, Black Canary's sonic scream, Black Lightning's lightning and Red… I was going to say they were about equal, but you made a very good point. as for that secret empire stuff on them falling to evil. Godzilla (Charged up) King Ghidorah. No. I'd say Cap. A lot. Superman stomps Cap, but then looks vaguely hurt and confused as to why the public likes Cap better than him. If Batman started killing criminals and measuring their justice by himself, he'd get immeasurably fucked in the head and probably devolve into some Dexter-type guy. Our Superman stands by the good morals he was taught, Red Son Superman stands by the good morals he was taught. This is a no contest. Support Out of Frame on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/OutofFrameShowWatch our newest video, "Who Ya Gonna Call? Here in the real world, however, Superman is more iconic. Hard. Also, I love the disparity in raw powers that both characters have, it makes more interesting the match up. You are indeed where you belong. Yeah there is absolutely no way Cap can pull this win. 1976. And Captain America kills people. Always more interesting to see a fight between a god and a man than richie boy vs captain america. For example, if Superman hit Captain Marvel with a mega-strong punch, that energy could be turned up to its absolute maximum and hit right back at Superman with even more force. Its superman for sure. If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit... then welcome home, my friend. It's implied the Injustice Superman was more immature compared to mainstream Superman, going off the prequel comics. Meanwhile, Cap is more close to Batman with his stronger than steel morals. You need not worry anymore as we are providing you with the most reliable information about Captain America vs Superman powers, enemies, key facts and much more. The fact that you have to attack Oscar and multiple award winning actress shows how Salty you have become. The simple fact is that Captain America is an all around great guy, but he doesn't need to try very hard at it. Sure, he has to go through the same challenges as a normal person does between choosing Good and Evil, but it's not as though he's regularly confronted with choosing more Good than other heroes choose. superman has been corrupted, brainwashed and being close to evil a lot of times. He doesn't avoid killing because he thinks people lile Joker should get to live, he does it because he doesn't trust himself to be a criminal's legal system. Edit: For clarity, compare only mainline canon from the comics. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Cap’s body is breakable, vulnerable. According to John Campea, who is known around the movie blogosphere, the negative response to Batman Vs.Superman affected Captain America: Civil War's box office.. Campea argues most of the general audience doesn't know the difference between a DC and a Marvel film, and that … Is this a fair comparison? What does Superman have to gain by immorality? If you feel like doing a bonus, discuss alternate versions/bonuses. The only people in a position to make him see he wasn't equipped to pull this off were countered by assholes like Injustice Hal and WW egging him on. You need not worry anymore as we are providing you with the most reliable information about Superman vs Captain America powers, enemies, key facts and much more. Press J to jump to the feed. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass! Supes crushes him, hes stronger in everyway, the speed difference alone makes it a stomp. He couldn't keep focus on every little thing, even then he still tried his best to not kill anyone. Apart from movies and TV series, many characters have started appearing in various games formats as well. The best Cap gets is villains who think he'd be a good asset. IMO it’s Captain America easily via he is and always has been mortal. I'll bring up Red Son only to say that the whole point of it was to show that goodness is subjective. Secondly, about two weeks ago Angela fought Thor and humiliated him because he was so slow. Sure, he has to go through the same challenges as a normal person does between choosing Good and Evil, but it's not as though he's regularly confronted with choosing more Good than other heroes choose. Superman vs Captain America Comparison. Marvel has announced that Captain America 3 will hit cinemas on May 6 2016 – exactly the same day that Warner Brothers’ (as yet untitled) Batman vs Superman flick will be released. Wonder Woman. Thor (Endgame, duel wield) Hulk. Amazo used Firestorms powers to create red sun radiation, incapacitating Superman. R2 - 616 Captain America. Superman has had to fight people of his own race who believe he should rule the planet due to his superiority. He does. Edit - Bonus round - 616 Cap and Comp Bollywood man fuse to take on MCU Thanos in a boxing match. Batman vs Superman is an interesting rivalry because there is a legit reason on why they would constantly fight. No. Cap gets stomped. Doomsday. One of Captain America's best buddies (Namor) is a terrorist that has killed god-knows-how-many civilians throughout the years. Loxley. Captain America is a hero known by all as the defender of FREEDOM in the Marvel universe. MCU where he just kills so many, many people in Winter Soldier. They also think he make a good ruler, not just a good asset. If a person has said "Superman is boring, he's unrelatable and overpowered" they are legally barred from watching any superhero movie for at least another five years, with options for renewal if they add "Batman should use his money to fix Gotham." There's an old saying that power corrupts, and having so much more power than Captain America could hope to and remaining uncorrupt is a feat in and of itself, but it's not just that. It looks like "Captain America 3" and "Batman vs. Superman" will challenge each other at the box office in May 2016, opening on the same day and pitting two rival movie studios against each other for the comic book audience. A single error made like throwing the hammer with its lightning and attempt to hit Superman. Supes's the kind of person who'd make a kid's year by blowing a few hours to play action figures with 'em. He failed it while Captain America was capable of doing it without strain. Captain America Comics #1 CGC 8.5, Marvel, 1941. Superman is way more powerful in all aspects. What does Captain America have to gain by immorality? Or the MCU where he just kills so many, many people in Winter Soldier. Not really, sure during WW2 he killed people, but it was only due to him being in the war. What are Captain America’s super powers? I'm not going to say he doesn't try peaceful options, but he's got a willingness to kill, especially when it comes to Nazis. Superman really does have to try harder because of his near godlike power - although I think being the Big Blue Boy Scout is so deeply ingrained in his nature that it would take something extraordinary to make him waver. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the whowouldwin community. And Captain America kills people. Also a Big Belly Burger. Superman and the Flash Wally West takes on Amazo and are easily beaten back. You are indeed where you belong. Captain Marvel has an array of superhuman abilities: super-strength, super-speed, enhance stamina and agility, flight, and the ability to project and absorb energy. Also, in the new Dark Nights: Metal, it's all about the different ways (alternate) Batmen become corrupted. Red Son proves your point even further. I think it's honestly the opposite, Cap's proven himself way more than Supes, That was against his will, and not the real Cap, The Ultimates when he's just... a jackass, That doesn't mean he doesn't have good morales. His spirits instantly lifted when he was given a mission. It was that Captain America is just patriotism the superhero, and Superman is overpowered. But all he ever wanted was to help people. Yeah Cap will have the shield and the hammer, but eventually Cap will make a mistake. Rodan. T he spring’s big comic-book movies feature the superhero trend du jour of good guys fighting one other: Batman takes on Superman, Team Captain America versus … One of the things that the Justice League movie got really, really right was how Batman realized that Superman was "more human" than he was. Superman is regularly given options to fall to corruption, taunted and teased with the power he could get if he was evil, and never gives in. As Batman v Superman lands in cinemas and Captain America: Civil War marches towards its release date, Huw Fullerton asks why this lazy device became the go-to superhero story In the epic battle between DC Comics and Dynamite Entertainment, let's roll the dice and bet on who would win in the ultimate fight between Homelander and Superman.Interestingly enough, The Boys was originally published through the DC Comics imprint, Wildstorm, before making the transition to Dynamite. You are indeed where you belong. Superman would already be planning out a counter attack before the hammer gets thrown. Aren't you keen on comparing Superman vs Black Panther films list?We are providing you a table where you can get a comparison list of their first live action movie. He could be more effective in combat with a bit more aggression, yes, but he's making do. for cap to become a hydra agent, they literally had to rewrite reality. Did you know Superman's first movie is Superman And The Mole Men (1951). All the deaths shellshocked him into thinking that the only way to reduce suffering in the world was to make sure people like the Joker weren't allowed to exist. Imagine if you were raised by ants - sure you’d empathize with them but how big do their problems look to you? To be fair, Injustice Superman became more of a monster than Cap could ever hope to be. Cap then says that Thunder Gods have always had a problem with their reflexes. Character wise, I would say Superman because he has to always keep himself in check so he won't abuse his power, having all that strength and keeping your sanity and your moral takes a strong willpower. Looking for a proper Superman Captain America Comparison?We know lots about All Superheroes and Super Villains but when it comes to choose the best from the lot, we are in a fix. Superman doesn't say "I'm superman", he doesn't even start with "I'm Kal-El". Superman may have helped popularize comics, but Captain Marvel is getting her due and … It's Superman. Cap has never seen any problem with that, has never tried to bring him to justice and sees no problem in having him as part of his team. Possibly the universe. Captain America just hasn't had the opportunity to prove himself as Good as Superman has, and he doesn't always have the luxury to make choices as Good as Superman does because he's so much weaker, but it's the comparison we have to make. Not too much. Captain Marvel has vast superpowers—including super-strength, stamina, durability, flight, energy generation and energy absorption. More evidence: In age of Ultron, during the weird Scarlet-Witch-mess-with-head section, Mind-Betty asks Cap to try to imagine a world with out war and Cap... can't. Captain america has business in India but just so happens to break the law, Bollywood fuse all of their cinematic Police officers into one to face him. He could literally rule the world. Superman is regularly given options to fall to corruption, taunted and teased with the power he could get if he was evil, and never gives in. Captain America vs Superman Comparison. If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit... then welcome home, my friend. Government or Ghostbusters? Worthy Captain America vs Superman , Both movie version , MCU Worthy Captain America vs DCEU Superman. You could put Cap with Iron Man and Thor from Endgame and the result would still be the same. So why didn't Captain America: Civil War open to $200 million at the box office? R3 - MCU Worthy Cap with Mjolnir. Cookies help us deliver our Services. A) Captain Marvel in Endgame or B)/Superman in Justice League. Captain America just hasn't had the opportunity to prove himself as Good as Superman has, and he doesn't always have the luxury to make choices as Good as Superman does because he's so much weaker, but it's the comparison we have to make. Wanda. And if the three of them can't do it, then Cap on his own definitely can't either. For more comparison of movies, you can visit Hulk vs Superman Movies List. Remember how in the Avengers movie he was destroying heavy bags because he felt useless? whereas Black Panther’s first movie is Captain America… Just a question - When Captain America lift hammer does physical strength of Thor also ??? His mind would process it in the seconds in between, already coming to the conclusion that now is the time to strike. This would probably resonate better with people than a flying alien who can blow up planets with his fists. Homelander, the team leader of the team, The Seven, is a superhero praised by the public … And then, though not perfect at it, Superman does try his best to avoid killing, even when it comes to enemy soldiers. Sensational copy of … Though not the main universe, Superman turned into an evil dictator after Lois Lane's death in the Injustice series. Guardians of the Galaxy (Vol 2) Captain Marvel. Superman is a good guy but I question how much he relates as he rarely has skin in the game as he’s basically a demigod. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The most perfect example of this is in the 2017 Wonder Woman Annual, where Wonder Woman needs to make sure that Batman and Superman are who they claim they are, so she makes them hold onto the lasso of truth and say who they are. ...Now, if anyone wants to start bringing Injustice or Red Son into this, I'm going to have to counter with the part where Captain America was a Hydra agent, or The Ultimates when he's just... a jackass. I'd say Cap 8/10 Vision. shouldnt be to hard to have him fight for the bad guys as long as he has something to do. They don't have the combined power or means to take on DCEU Superman. The simple fact is that Captain America is an all around great guy, but he doesn't need to try very hard at it. Also, Lois's death wasn't the only thing contributing to breaking Superman in Injustice. UP UNTIL THE MID-1970s, the rivalry between DC and Marvel Comics, the two largest comics publishers in North America, meant that any collaboration was unthinkable.There were plenty of stories showing Batman and Superman working together, but fans of, say, Batman and Spider-Man hoping to see the two of them work together were just plain out of luck. Superman, on the other hand, faces serious moral challenges every day and rises above them. Mothra. The thing about Superman is that he has all these amazing powers and yes he is an alien from space, but he doesn't see himself much more than just a rural bumpkin from Kansas. Flash. 8 years ago Dat S and cape. Yes. It'd be like if people harped on Darkseid's loss to Superman as proof Darkseid's weak. Friendship/10. Five super soldiers duke it out to determine which one is the best warrior of them all. Cyborg. Cap loves violence. He doesn't try to turn evil or rule the world, he stands by what he believed to be good. Round 1: Superman and Captain America nod at each other in mutual admiration. His city got nuked. His very first thought is "Clark Kent". Hulk vs Superman Games List. Just like in Justice League when Superman was able to block Aquaman, Wonder Woman, and Cyborg, he still was able to see what Flash was doing at super speed, plan out an attack, and act accordingly. R1 - MCU Captain america. Meanwhile, Batman says "Batman," not "Bruce Wayne". I'm not going to say he doesn't try peaceful options, but he's got a willingness to kill, especially when it comes to Nazis. The best Cap gets is villains who think he'd be a good asset. Personal preference, Captain America because he's way more cooler for me atleast. Blame Batman Vs.Superman?!. If he put someone with the ability to rule, like Aquaman, in charge, he probably could have pulled off his vision and never become a bad dude. Steve basks in the light of Superman. Cap is only content when he is AT war. Homoerotic Friendship/10. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass! A lot. Cap's the kind of person who'd make a kid's day by taking a picture with them. ... knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit... then welcome home, my friend. Superman. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. And Cap’s a Hydra agent in a non-Elseworld comic line, kinda negates that. Press J to jump to the feed. Cap has also faced the same kind of people. That said, using that as proof Captain America beats Juggernaut is lowballing Hulk. for speed, when Thunderstrike was on the Avengers, he was out into a reflex test. I changed my tune once I actually took the time to get to know these characters better. Aquaman. Dude loves his Big Belly Burgers. In short, they’re too flawless to be complex characters. now, i dont know much on all the occasions supes has been close to evil, and brainwashed is also not a fair comparision, but a bit far from rewriting reality. Round 2: In close quarters Superman is brought to tears by Cap's moral fortitude. "Captain America: Civil War" gets right almost everything that the dull, serious and chaotic "Batman vs. Superman" got wrong. Looking for a proper Captain America Superman Comparison?We know lots about All Superheroes and Super Villains but when it comes to choose the best from the lot, we are in a fix. Superman is an illegal alien who, in many timelines, rules the world with an iron fist. Considering that DCEU Superman can stomp MCU Thor, it's not looking good for Cap. Superman is the symbol of moral righteousness in the DC universe. Worthy Captain America vs Superman , Both movie version , MCU Worthy Captain America vs DCEU Superman. All fights are in-character random encounters unless stated ot New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the whowouldwin community. It's Superman. We provide you a sorted Hulk vs Superman games list. No.